Why A Maintainer of the Linux Graphics Driver Nouveau Stepped Down
For over a decade Karol Herbst has been a developer on the open-source Nouveau driver, a reverse-engineered NVIDIA graphics driver for Linux. "He went on to become employed by Red Hat," notes Phoronix. "While he's known more these days for his work on the Mesa 3D Graphics Library and the Rusticl OpenCL driver for it, he's still remained a maintainer of the Nouveau kernel driver."
But Saturday Herbst stepped down as a nouveau kernel maintainer, in a mailing list message that begins "I was pondering with myself for a while if I should just make it official that I'm not really involved in the kernel community anymore, neither as a reviewer, nor as a maintainer." (Another message begins "I often thought about at least contributing some patches again once I find the time, but...")
Their resignation message hints at some long-running unhappiness. "I got burned out enough by myself caring about the bits I maintained, but eventually I had to realize my limits. The obligation I felt was eating me from inside. It stopped being fun at some point and I reached a point where I simply couldn't continue the work I was so motivated doing as I've did in the early days." And they point to one specific discussion on the kernel mailing list February 8th as "The moment I made up my mind."
It happened in a thread about whether Rust would create difficulty for maintainers. (Someone had posted that "The all powerful sub-system maintainer model works well if the big technology companies can employ omniscient individuals in these roles, but those types are a bit hard to come by.") In response, someone else had posted "I'll let you in a secret. The maintainers are not 'all-powerful'. We are the 'thin blue line' that is trying to keep the code to be maintainable and high quality. Like most leaders of volunteer organization, whether it is the Internet Engineerint Task Force (the standards body for the Internet), we actually have very little power. We can not *command* people to work on retiring technical debt, or to improve testing infrastructure, or work on some particular feature that we'd very like for our users. All we can do is stop things from being accepted..."
Saturday Herbst wrote:
The moment I made up my mind about this was reading the following words written by a maintainer within the kernel community:
"we are the thin blue line"
This isn't okay. This isn't creating an inclusive environment. This isn't okay with the current political situation especially in the US. A maintainer speaking those words can't be kept. No matter how important or critical or relevant they are. They need to be removed until they learn. Learn what those words mean for a lot of marginalized people. Learn about what horrors it evokes in their minds.
I can't in good faith remain to be part of a project and its community where those words are tolerated. Those words are not technical, they are a political statement. Even if unintentionally, such words carry power, they carry meanings one needs to be aware of. They do cause an immense amount of harm.
The phrase thin blue line "typically refers to the concept of the police as the line between law-and-order and chaos," according to Wikipedia, but more recently became associated with a"countermovement" to the Black Lives Matter movement and "a number of far-right movements in the U.S."
Phoronix writes:
Lyude Paul and Danilo Krummrich both of Red Hat remain Nouveau kernel maintainers. Red Hat developers are also working on developing NOVA as the new Rust-based open-source NVIDIA kernel driver leveraging the GSP interface for Turing GPUs and newer.
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
Julianne Moore 'stunned' after Trump admin bans her children's book about freckles
The Still Alice star, 64, revealed her first book, Freckleface Strawberry, is barred from schools run by the Department of Defense.
The purrrfect journey! Meet the adventurous cat who took a train into London alone - leaving its owner baffled
The ticket officer must have been surprised when he caught a cat that travelled 17.7 miles by train from Surrey to London Waterloo - solo.
Britain wastes BILLIONS on foreign projects like shrimp farms in Bangladesh and electric Porsches for Albanian jails - while at-home needs 'miss out'
The revelations follow mounting pressure to raise defence spending while Vladimir Putin's forces gain ground in Ukraine and as Britain continues to dish out around £15billion per year on overseas aid.
Military chiefs tell Keir Starmer they need a 'national arsenal' of futuristic weapons or risk going to war with Russia
Britain's military chiefs have told Keir Starmer that he needs to give the Armed Forces a 'national arsenal' of futuristic weapons or else he risks war with Russia.
Primark's new spring clothing range shoppers are controversially divided on
They have released their new range ahead of the change in season
Everyday gadget could be making you go deaf and it's nothing to do with the volume, experts warn
The condition, called auditory processing disorder (APD), sees the brain struggle to decipher sounds or words and differentiate them against background noise.
Summer camp teacher claiming £300,000 in damages after she was knocked down by children playing 'banned' British Bulldog
Elizabeth Parkin (pictured), 45, said it meant she was out of work for around four months with a serious leg injury - which left her with a limp and potentially needing a knee replacement.
Couple arrested in Iran 'could have been held just because they are British': Pressure builds on Government to help bring them home
The British tourists who are being held in custody in Iran as they motorbiked across the world may have been arrested simply for 'being British', according to reports.
Jimmy Mizen's killer 'posts new rap video on TikTok' despite him being recalled to prison for at least a year
Jake Fahri was given a life sentence for the killing of 16-year-old Jimmy in 2008 when he threw a glass dish at him fatally injuring the teenager.
Delhi hit by 'massive' 4.0 earthquake: Locals seen fleeing their homes to safety as aftershocks rattled the city
Tremors were felt in India's capital city as well as other northern parts of the country, reported India Today.
Prince Harry and the Canadian Prime Minister pose for selfies while cheering on the final sport match of the Invictus Games
The PM draped himself in a scarf from New Zealand supporters while waiting for Harry to arrive, happily accepting every photo request.
Israeli minister reveals he will vote AGAINST the next round of hostage releases as he says the 'deal signals weakness'
An Israeli minister has revealed he will oppose the second stage of the hostage release deal with Hamas, claiming it 'signals weakness.'
The cosmos has some acts of kindness in store, says JEMIMA CAINER - by opening up, all the signs will be able to appreciate the beauty in the world
JEMIMA CAINER: A positive trine connection between the Moon, in justice- focused Libra, and the Sun, in fair-minded Aquarius, inspires us to see the beauty that can be found when we give freely.
Bali bombings hero Erik de Haart, 67, dies suddenly after he saved countless lives in 2002 terrorist attack which killed 88 Aussies
Erik de Haart was in Kuta with the Coogee Dolphins rugby league team at the time of the terror attacks and pulled so many wounded victims from the wreckage he lost count.
Sharon Stone in talks to join Euphoria season 3 as star-studded cast kick off production for long-awaited return
Shortly after HBO announced that production had begun, it was revealed that the 66-year-old actress is currently in talks to join the star-studded cast.
Spending on university campus diversity staff skyrockets to massive £28million a year - with one boss on an eye-watering six-figure sum
The figures reveal that costs for equality, diversity and inclusion workers has doubled in the space of three years.
Multi-millionaire business tycoon blasted by environmentalists after his unauthorised cliff top summer house damages clifftop
Bill Buckler has permanently damaged the seaside cliff after piling concrete pillars into it for the foundations of the 60ft wide structure, according to environment group Natural England.
Man dies in hospital after police raced to a home following reports a child was being assaulted
Metropolitan Police officers were called to High Street, south Norwood in the early hours of Sunday February 16, where they found a man, aged 45, who was experiencing a medical emergency.
Zelensky issues red line on Ukraine-Russia peace deal as Trump sparks meltdown in Europe
Ukraine must be involved in any negotiations for a peace deal with Russia, President Volodymyr Zelensky insisted on Sunday.