What's the Best Ways for Humans to Explore Space?
Should we leave space exploration to robots — or prioritize human spaceflight, making us a multiplanetary species?
Harvard professor Robin Wordsworth, who's researched the evolution and habitability of terrestrial-type planets, shares his thoughts:
In space, as on Earth, industrial structures degrade with time, and a truly sustainable life support system must have the capability to rebuild and recycle them. We've only partially solved this problem on Earth, which is why industrial civilization is currently causing serious environmental damage. There are no inherent physical limitations to life in the solar system beyond Earth — both elemental building blocks and energy from the sun are abundant — but technological society, which developed as an outgrowth of the biosphere, cannot yet exist independently of it. The challenge of building and maintaining robust life-support systems for humans beyond Earth is a key reason why a machine-dominated approach to space exploration is so appealing...
However, it's notable that machines in space have not yet accomplished a basic task that biology performs continuously on Earth: acquiring raw materials and utilizing them for self-repair and growth. To many, this critical distinction is what separates living from non-living systems... The most advanced designs for self-assembling robots today begin with small subcomponents that must be manufactured separately beforehand. Overall, industrial technology remains Earth-centric in many important ways. Supply chains for electronic components are long and complex, and many raw materials are hard to source off-world... If we view the future expansion of life into space in a similar way as the emergence of complex life on land in the Paleozoic era, we can predict that new forms will emerge, shaped by their changed environment, while many historical characteristics will be preserved. For machine technology in the near term, evolution in a more life-like direction seems likely, with greater focus on regenerative parts and recycling, as well as increasingly sophisticated self-assembly capabilities. The inherent cost of transporting material out of Earth's gravity well will provide a particularly strong incentive for this to happen.
If building space habitats is hard and machine technology is gradually developing more life-like capabilities, does this mean we humans might as well remain Earth-bound forever? This feels hard to accept because exploration is an intrinsic part of the human spirit... To me, the eventual extension of the entire biosphere beyond Earth, rather than either just robots or humans surrounded by mechanical life-support systems, seems like the most interesting and inspiring future possibility. Initially, this could take the form of enclosed habitats capable of supporting closed-loop ecosystems, on the moon, Mars or water-rich asteroids, in the mold of Biosphere 2. Habitats would be manufactured industrially or grown organically from locally available materials. Over time, technological advances and adaptation, whether natural or guided, would allow the spread of life to an increasingly wide range of locations in the solar system.
The article ponders the benefits (and the history) of both approaches — with some fasincating insights along the way.
"If genuine alien life is out there somewhere, we'll have a much better chance of comprehending it once we have direct experience of sustaining life beyond our home planet."
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
British holidaymakers face paying an extra £21 on flight tax as Labour strikes deal with the EU on carbon emissions
Sir Keir Starmer agreed a 'substantial package' of agreements with Brussels in May this year (pictured) that includes a commitment to reducing carbon emissions.
STEPHEN GLOVER: Davie had to go but who believes it will really change the woke sect that the BBC has become?
Nearly a week has passed since we learned about a leaked report showing how BBC's Panorama had doctored a speech by Donald Trump to make him say something that he hadn't actually said.
Beloved antique shop in Essex to close after 50 years of business
Terry's Antiques & Secondhand, in Station Road, Walton, will be closing for the final time this week, after 50 years of business.
Female TikTok star is kidnapped and publicly executed by al-Qaeda jihadists in Mali as yet another African nation descends into chaos
Jihadists in Mali have kidnapped and executed a female TikTok star after accusing her of filming them and collaborating with the army.
Pharmacist reveals the medications to NEVER mix with alcohol: 'Patients have felt close to death... it's serious'
A leading pharmacist has revealed the medications that you should never mix with alcohol -warning that it's not worth the potentially dangerous side effects.
Moment GMB stars Susanna Reid and Richard Madeley clash on live TV in row over the BBC and Tim Davie
Mr Davie and BBC News CEO Deborah Turness stepped down on Sunday amid an impartiality row which has rocked the national broadcaster after an internal report accused it of bias and censorship.
'I think it's worth worrying about' PETER HITCHENS says Trump will 'try quite hard' to have a third term in the White House and here's how he'll do it
There is a way that Donald Trump can have a third term at the White House. But will the President who enjoys and wants power cash on it for another run?
Putin's DAUGHTER 'is behind campaign to bring down foreign minister Sergei Lavrov as she tries to bring an end to Ukraine war'
Last week, reports indicated that the president had sidelined Lavrov, 75, has been in charge of foreign policy for more than two decades.
Everything you need to know about train services at Beaulieu Park station
Essex passengers can now experience faster travel into London after the opening of Beaulieu Park station last month.
Everything you need to know about train services at Beaulieu Park station
Essex passengers can now experience faster travel into London after the opening of Beaulieu Park station last month.
Beloved family-run antiques shop to shut down for good after 50 years
The beloved shop was opened in 1975 but its owners are now retiring
KATHERINE SPENLEY: I'm a 49-year-old lifestyle editor and I've tried ten lipstick balms to find the most anti-ageing. These are my top three...
Welcome to Inspire's new Tried & Tested column, where, every week, we'll put a selection of beauty products through their paces. This week I've road-tested a fair few new lipstick balms.
Is heavy drinking as a teen GOOD for you? Youngsters who booze with their friends go on to earn more as adults, controversial study claims
It's a rite of passage that's regularly frowned upon - but drinking with friends in your late teens could boost career prospects, a controversial study claims.
'Startled' Antiques Roadshow guests can't contain their shock as they learn eye-watering value of 'extraordinary' albums bought for just £5
BBC 's Fiona Bruce returned to host the programme from Lister Park and Cartwright Hall in Bradford, where guests brought in their prized possessions to be evaluated.
Allianz UK joins growing list of Clop’s Oracle E-Business Suite victims
Insurance giant’s UK arm says cybercriminals misattributed the real victim
Allianz UK confirms it was one of the many companies that fell victim to the Clop gang's Oracle E-Business Suite (EBS) attack after crims reported that they had attacked a subsidiary.…
Cancer-stricken Davina McCall, Myleene Klass and Twiggy join a string of midlife stars on the first ever HELLO! Second Act Power List
This collective of women, spanning TV, fashion, philanthropy, literature, beauty and activism, take centre stage on a stunning cover shoot, cementing their status as role models for a new generation.
How to plot your way through the inheritance tax minefield if you DON'T have children
If you're opposed to inheritance tax, you probably believe it's unfair to be forced to hand over hard-earned wealth to an undeserving Government.
Asylum seekers may be given £100 a week to leave taxpayer-funded hotels and go and live with family or friends in UK
UK ministers are desperate to find ways to move migrants out of hotels, which cost an average per migrant of £145 each night.
Donald Trump makes stunning flyover for first NFL visit of the season... hours after it emerged he wants $3.7bn new stadium named after him
Trump was seen arriving at the Commanders' showdown with the Lions just hours after it emerged he wants the Washington team to name their new $3.7billion stadium after him.