VPN Providers Consider Exiting France Over 'Dangerous' Blocking Demands
An anonymous reader quotes a report from TorrentFreak: In France, rightsholders have taken legal action to compel large VPN providers to support their pirate site blocking program. The aim is to reinforce existing blocking measures, but VPN providers see this as a dangerous move, leading to potential security issues and overblocking. As a result, some are considering leaving France altogether if push comes to shove. [...] Earlier this month, sports rightsholders Canal+ and LFP requested blocking injunctions that would require popular VPNs to start blocking pirate sites and services. The full requests are not public, but the details available show that Cyberghost, ExpressVPN, NordVPN, ProtonVPN, and Surfshark are listed as respondents. [...]
The blocking request has yet to be approved and several of the targeted VPN providers have reserved detailed commentary, for now. That said, the VPN Trust Initiative (VTI), which includes ExpressVPN, NordVPN and Surfshark as members, has been vocal in its opposition. VTI is part of the i2Coalition and while it doesn't speak directly for any of the members, the coalition's Executive Director Christian Dawson has been in regular discussions with VPN providers. From this, it became clear that VPN providers face difficult decisions. If VPN providers are ordered to block pirate sites, some are considering whether to follow in the footsteps of Cisco, which discontinued its OpenDNS service in the country, to avoid meddling with its DNS resolver.
Speaking with TorrentFreak, VTI's Dawson says that VPNs have previously left markets like India and Pakistan in response to restrictive requirements. This typically happens when privacy or security principles are at risk, or if the technical implementation of blocking measures is infeasible. VTI does not rule out that some members may choose to exit France for similar reasons, if required to comply with blocking measures. "We've seen this before in markets like India and Pakistan, where regulatory requirements forced some VPN services to withdraw rather than compromise on encryption standards or log-keeping policies," Dawson says. "France's potential move to force VPN providers to block content could put companies in a similar position -- where they either comply with measures that contradict their purpose or leave the market altogether." "This case in France is part of a broader global trend of regulatory overreach, where governments attempt to control encrypted services under the guise of content regulation. We've already seen how China, Russia, Myanmar, and Iran have imposed VPN restrictions as part of broader censorship efforts."
"The best path forward is for policymakers to focus on targeted enforcement measures that don't undermine Internet security or create a precedent for global Internet fragmentation," concludes Dawson. "As seen in other cases, blanket blocking measures do not effectively combat piracy but instead create far-reaching consequences that disrupt the open Internet."
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
Jury discharged in trial of former public school hockey coach accused of murdering his wife
The panel of seven men and four women told Mr Justice Choudhury they were deadlocked after spending nine hours and 46 minutes deliberating over the fate of Mohamed Samak.
Will Laura Whitmore ever return to TV? Love Island star has turned her back on her glittering telly career with an audience of millions to tread the boards in local theatres
Laura has had a monumental career shift over the past five years, ditching her glittering TV career to play to theatre audiences of just 300.
Why IS television so obsessed with incest? As White Lotus shocks viewers, experts reveal why the 'last taboo' has become mainstream
The White Lotus has shocked viewers around the world with its depiction of incest in season three, but it's not the only show to have embraced the taboo.
MARK PALMER: Luis Rubiales' kiss was a crass error of judgement, but finding him guilty of sexual assault gives in to the #MeToo mob mentality that all jubilant males are predators
Luis Rubiales was found guilty of sexual assault for landing a 'spontaneous' kiss on the lips of Spanish footballer Jenni Hermoso after her team won the 2023 Women's World Cup in Sydney.
Teacher is sacked after 35 years because one pupil didn't understand joke about 'whacking' kids if they flunked a test
Baiklautchmee Subrian took Gilbert Colvin Primary School in Ilford, east London, to an employment tribunal after she was dismissed for making the comment to a small class of Year 6 pupils.
Horror unseen footage shows moment police rush towards Southport dance studio while killer is inside as hero bystanders scream 'you need f***ing gun' - before teenage knifeman is arrested
The terrified local can be heard shouting these remarks to police outside the Hart Space building in Southport after Axel Rudakubana had killed three children in July last year.
Furious Zelensky 'screamed at Trump's envoy for trying to make him sign $500billion mineral deal - and was so loud he could be heard through the door and left US treasury secretary shaking'
Recalling the president's fury, Ukrainian lawmakers claimed Zelensky's bellows reverberated through the halls of Kyiv's presidential palace as he laid into the US Treasury Secretary
Burberry draws a VERY glitzy crowd as Brooklyn Beckham and his wife Nicola Peltz join Rosie Huntington-Whiteley, Geri Halliwell and Orlando Bloom attending heritage brand's LFW show
The stars were out in force for Burberry's London Fashion Week show on Monday held at the Tate Britain.
Primark's £16 jeans 'the most wanted' for Spring shoppers 'love'
Shoppers loved it for its versatility
M. Macron lifted a haw-he-haw Gallic eyebrow as Trump grimaced like a tortoise: QUENTIN LETTS watches the French President enter Donald's lair
There is no man better for flagornerie than the French president, Emmanuel Macron, who can make the most blatant exercise in sucking-up sound ornate and rather Louis Quatorze.
Glimmer of hope as No10 'recognises the strength of feeling' over Big Tech AI raid - as iconic creatives across the country back call to 'make it fair'
Downing Street conceded that its controversial proposal to give AI firms a copyright exception may not emerge as the final option following a powerful campaign by the Mail.
One person dead after four injured in bus and car crash in Harrow
Emergency were rushed to the scene around 9pm on Monday after getting calls about the smash on Whitmore Road in Harrow.
Despite Wall Street jitters, AI hopefuls keep spending billions on AI infrastructure
Sunk cost fallacy? No, I just need a little more cash for this AGI thing I’ve been working on
Comment Despite persistent worries that vast spending on AI infrastructure may not pay for itself, cloud providers, hyperscalers, and datacenter operators have continued to shovel billions of dollars into ever-larger GPU clusters.…
Ozempic could be prescribed to treat depression - as major study shows weight loss jabs boost mental health
The startling findings raise the possibility that the medicines, originally developed to treat diabetes, could one day be offered as a mental health therapy, say experts.
Trump issues dire WWIII warning if Russia-Ukraine deal not worked out as he meets Macron
President Emmanuel Macron of France became the first European leader to meet Trump at the White House Monday, as the continent rallies its arguments in defense of Ukraine.
Drunk wife from hell barks orders at Florida police as she's hauled off flight and arrested
Body cam footage showed a Michigan woman getting escorted off an Allegiant plane at a Florida airport and later being arrested after she continually barked orders at her embarrassed husband.
Education Secretary warns of a school absence 'epidemic' - as damning figures reveal a third of children have tried to miss school this year
The survey of families by charity Parentkind found 31 per cent of pupils have shirked school, equivalent to 3.3 million.
Two Hungarian sisters, 32, who vanished in Aberdeen sparking a major search died from drowning
Henrietta and Eliza Huszti, both 32, disappeared on January 7 before their bodies were found in the River Dee on January 31 near where they were last spotted in Aberdeen.
Belgian festival-goers fume as centuries-old custom of drinking LIVE FISH is banned on cruelty grounds
The ban, which came into force last summer, sparked an outcry among traditionalists, who took to the streets over the weekend to demand the reinstatement of the ritual.