Supreme Court Hears Case On How To Label Risks of Popular Weed Killer
An anonymous reader quotes a report from NPR: A divided U.S. Supreme Court on Monday heard a dispute over labels on the popular Roundup weed killer, which thousands of people blame for their cancers. How the Supreme Court rules could have implications for tens of thousands of lawsuits against Roundup maker Monsanto, which is now owned by Bayer. The case centers on who decides about warning labels on chemicals: the federal government -- or states or juries. [...] The justices will not be evaluating whether glyphosate causes cancer. Rather, they'll consider who should decide what appears on warning labels and whether states have a role to play after the EPA weighs in.
The current U.S. solicitor general backed Monsanto. Sarah Harris, his principal deputy, said the Environmental Protection Agency is in the driver's seat, not anyone in Missouri. "Missouri thus requires adding cancer warnings but federal law requires EPA to approve new warnings and tasks EPA with deciding what label changes would mitigate any health risks," Harris argued. "State law must give way." Several justices, including Brett Kavanaugh, appeared to agree with Monsanto's argument about the need for a single, uniform standard across the country.
But others, like Chief Justice John Roberts, wondered what would happen if the federal government moved more slowly than states did, who wanted to act quickly on information about new dangers. "Well, it does undermine the uniformity," Roberts said. "On the other hand, if it turns out they were right, it might have been good if they had an opportunity to do something, to call this danger to the attention of people while the federal government was going through its process," he said about states.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson asked about the emergence of new science, and the EPA's reviews. "There's a 15-year window between when that product has to be re-registered again and lots of things can happen in science, in terms of development about the product," she said. Bayer, which now owns Monsanto, only sells Roundup that contains glyphosate to farmers and businesses these days. Bayer has been pushing to resolve scores of the residential cases through a sweeping settlement, trying to put the costly claims behind it.
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
Lori Loughlin, 61, hit by claims she 'got facelift from Kris Jenner's celebrity surgeon'… as his staggering prices are revealed
The Full House star , 61, set tongues wagging when she stepped out sporting a bold new look in Los Angeles earlier this month.
Amandaland series two launch date is confirmed with the social climbing 'mumfluencer' set to return to screens next week
The BBC have now confirmed the series will return to screens on May 6 - with six episodes set to air over the coming weeks.
Bright green parcel locker 'plonked' on quiet cul-de-sac is removed less than a month later following 'outrage' from residents
Homeowners on a on a quiet cul-de-sac in Coventry, were 'up in arms' after the 8ft-tall delivery locker was dropped on their doorsteps earlier this month.
How to track down lost pensions and old work pots
Now everyone is auto enrolled into a new pension each time they change job we are all building up ever more pots - here's how to keep track.
Two boys, one and three, who died in house fire in Wolverhampton are named
Firefighters brought the children outside but they were tragically pronounced dead at the scene.
Still listen to Diddy and R. Kelly? Study reveals how grim revelations about artists can actually BOOST the popularity of their music
Experts from Cornell University have revealed how grim revelations about artists do not put fans off listening to their music.
Stephen Miller's wife sets record straight over cruel claims husband was using her as 'human shield' during assassination attempt
Katie Miller has defended her husband after rumors circulated that he used her as a human shield when a gunman opened fire outside the White House Correspondents' dinner on Saturday night.
Counter terror police probe another Golders Green arson attack as memorial wall to protesters killed in Iran is targeted overnight
Detectives are probing an attempt to set fire to a memorial wall dedicated to the fallen victims of the Iranian regime, in north-west London.
Barman sent selfies of himself in a car with three children shortly before attempting to kill them in a high-speed crash, woman tells court
Tancredo Bankhardt, 41, allegedly put the image on Instagram before accelerating up to 74mph and veering on to the wrong side of the 60mph limit road.
The Devil Wears Prada 2 is accused of 'blatant racism' as criticism mounts over sequel's 'lazy' and 'stereotypical' portrayal of an Asian character
Cinema-goers have expressed dismay with distributor 20th Century Studios over its handling of new character Jin Chao, an enthusiastic Asian intern played by Helen J Shen.
Armed police arrest teenage boy after car chase through Colchester
The teenager has been arrested on suspicion of stealing a car and other offences, including driving without a license
Real reason White House Correspondents' Dinner alleged shooter left Kash Patel off his chilling kill list manifesto
White House Correspondents' Association Dinner suspected gunman Cole Thomas Allen said he wanted to kill all of the Trump administration's top officials, except one.
Terror at 130mph: First images from inside Spanish train crash disaster that claimed 46 lives are revealed by investigators
The pictures, included in a Civil Guard report now submitted to a judge in Montoro, show the impact of tearing through the rear carriages just before the lights went out.
Big Brother legend Nadia Almada, 49, is unrecognisable as she appears bandaged and bruised after undergoing facelift in Turkey
Big Brother legend Nadia Almada appeared totally unrecognisable as she emerged from a Turkish hospital after undergoing a facelift.
Men everywhere secretly have the same complaint about their sex lives. It's NOT about looks or frequency... I was shocked at first - but if women knew the truth, it would save marriages: JANA HOCKING
After years of enduring 'Mr Jackhammer', it turns out men aren't exactly wowed by women's moves in the bedroom either. There's apparently a common sin even I am guilty of...
Health chiefs issue urgent recall for antidepressants prescribed to millions due to manufacturing error: 'Seek medical advice immediately'
Millions of patients on antidepressants are being urged to check their tablets after a manufacturing error led to two drugs being packaged incorrectly.
We installed doggy cams in our home to check on our German Pointers while in Thailand - but never imagined we'd catch our trusted pet sitters abusing them
Paige Williams, of Knowle, West Midlands, charged the the family £1,400 to care for the pets in their absence.
Man appears to nod off as Morgan McSweeney gives evidence to MPs on Mandelson vetting
Sir Keir Starmer's former chief of staff was giving evidence to the Foreign Affairs Committee in relation to the appointment of Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.
Michael Jackson biopic sparks an 'annoying' new trend of fancy dress-clad cinema-goers 'ruining' the movie by 'dancing and moonwalking' throughout
Michael Jackson's biopic has sparked debate among cinema-goers.