The Growing Problem With China's Unreliable Numbers
Chinese economist Gao Shanwen told a Washington panel in December that China's real GDP growth might be around 2% rather than the official figure near 5%. By January, Gao was no longer chief economist at SDIC Securities and went silent for almost a year.
As FT points out in a long piece, China does not publish quarterly GDP breakdowns showing consumption, investment and net exports. Every other major economy produces these figures.
The IMF in 2024 gave China a C grade for national accounts. The rating puts China on par with India and below Vietnam. Fixed asset investment data showed negative growth in 2025 for only the second time in decades. Property investment has fallen consistently since 2022. But official GDP investment data shows no signs of declining.
The National Bureau of Statistics stopped publishing sectoral breakdowns of fixed asset investment in 2018. It discontinued a price series in 2021 and a land sales series in 2023. Beijing has restricted researcher access rather than addressing longstanding questions about data quality. China says it disagrees with the IMF's C rating. The government argued its production-side GDP approach is appropriate.
Why does it matter? China is too large and too interconnected with the global economy for unreliable data to be a purely domestic issue. The lack of transparency creates problems for everyone trying to make decisions based on understanding China's economic trajectory. As Eswar Prasad, a professor at Cornell University and former IMF official, told FT: China is one of the two biggest economies in the world. "It would be nice to know what is really going on."
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
Your ultimate winter shopping guide. From everyday denim to your essential Christmas party outfit, our fashion editor has found the most stylish, confidence-boosting staples for your cold-weather wardrobe - plus what to avoid: DINAH VAN TULLEKEN
Today marks the end of my transitional wardrobe. A glance at the forecast (or indeed out the window) tells me it's time to dress for actual winter.
Universal's huge UK theme park to get its own railway station - with work set to cost up to £6 billion
The new Universal theme park set to come to the UK will even get its very own train station.
'Proud' father Keir Starmer shares letter to his teenage son as PM says it's the 'highlight of my week' to watch Arsenal together - and reveals strained relationship with his own Dad
The Prime Minister told his eldest child, aged 17, how 'proud' he is of him and how sharing a takeaway or watching Arsenal matches together are 'the highlights of my week'.
Meet Bluey's REAL parents: Actors who voice megastar cartoon dog's family are unmasked - with some fans asking: 'Is it okay to fancy Bandit Heeler?'
The actors who voice the characters of Bluey's parents, Chilli and Bandit, in the hit TV show, Melanie Zanetti and Dave McCormack, appeared on The One Show this week.
Ford rolls into the Xen Project as hypervisor gears up for autos
Version 4.21 also brings advances in the datacenter, on ARM, and RISC-V
The Xen Project today delivered a major release of its hypervisor and associated tools, including contributions from automaker Ford, which quietly joined the project in June.…
International Men's Day – What is it and which charities offer help
International Men's Day highlights positive role models and raises awareness of men’s well-being.
'We're all responsible' - Emergency services speak on Road Safety Week
Partners across Essex joined together in SERP to raise awareness about road safety with a poignant memorial for fatal collisions.
Essex media group CEO accused of unpaid wages of up to £10,000 by former staff
A group of former employees from Essex-based Kube Media Limited have raised serious concerns over repeatedly late missing wage payments.
Three Essex Claire's Accessories stores set to disappear from high streets
Claires' parent company filed for administration in August
Witham vet practice becomes employee-owned thanks to funding boost
Brookend Veterinary Practice in Witham has become employee-owned after receiving six figures worth of funding.
'We're all responsible' - Emergency services speak on Road Safety Week
Partners across Essex joined together in SERP to raise awareness about road safety with a poignant memorial for fatal collisions.
International Men's Day – What is it and which charities offer help
International Men's Day highlights positive role models and raises awareness of men’s well-being.
Essex media group CEO accused of unpaid wages of up to £10,000 by former staff
A group of former employees from Essex-based Kube Media Limited have raised serious concerns over repeatedly late missing wage payments.
Starmer fights to cling on as rebel MP offers to give up his Commons seat so Andy Burnham can become leader - with '80 backbenchers behind challenger'
Left-winger Clive Lewis said he does not believe the PM can recover from dire polls, with a disastrous Budget and local elections looming.
Porsche's new Cayenne Electric is its most powerful road car EVER - here's five things you need to know about it
Porsche bosses say the new Cayenne Electric will
'set a new standard in the SUV segment'. Here's five reasons why...
Man who claimed bulge in his trousers was 'all him' faces 20 years in prison after bizarre truth was revealed
Jesse Agus Martinez, 35, was asked about the contents of his pants after observers noticed a suspiciously large bulge - but what he showed them has landed him in hot water.
Ricky Gervais returns to Netflix with 'most honest and confessional show so far' - and it's just weeks away from hitting screens
The comedian, 64, announced his highly-anticipated fourth stand-up special on Wednesday which is set for release on December 30.
Moment Range Rover gang tear metal gates off jewellers before swiping £40,000 haul in expertly-planned four-minute heist
Clayden & Co Jewellers, in the historic Arcade in Bognor Regis, was turned into a wreckage-strewn crime scene at 2.15am last Tuesday, after the thieves smashed their way in.
I plunged into hell after dying on the operating table. The devil tortured me in the most heinous way... then God arrived
Camille Gent from Oregon told the Daily Mail in vivid detail about what happened when she plunged into hell after being in a coma for 13 days.