Python 'Chardet' Package Replaced With LLM-Generated Clone, Re-Licensed
Ancient Slashdot reader ewhac writes: The maintainers of the Python package `chardet`, which attempts to automatically detect the character encoding of a string, announced the release of version 7 this week, claiming a speedup factor of 43x over version 6. In the release notes, the maintainers claim that version 7 is, "a ground-up, MIT-licensed rewrite of chardet." Problem: The putative "ground-up rewrite" is actually the result of running the existing copyrighted codebase and test suite through the Claude LLM. In so doing, the maintainers claim that v7 now represents a unique work of authorship, and therefore may be offered under a new license. Version 6 and earlier was licensed under the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL). Version 7 claims to be available under the MIT license.
The maintainers appear to be claiming that, under the Oracle v. Google decision, which found that cloning public APIs is fair use, their v7 is a fair use re-implementation of the `chardet` public API. However, there is no evidence to suggest their re-write was under "clean room" conditions, which traditionally has shielded cloners from infringement suits. Further, the copyrightability of LLM output has yet to be settled. Recent court decisions seem to favor the view that LLM output is not copyrightable, as the output is not primarily the result of human creative expression -- the endeavor copyright is intended to protect. Spirited discussion has ensued in issue #327 on `chardet`s GitHub repo, raising the question: Can copyrighted source code be laundered through an LLM and come out the other end as a fresh work of authorship, eligible for a new copyright, copyright holder, and license terms? If this is found to be so, it would allow malicious interests to completely strip-mine the Open Source commons, and then sell it back to the users without the community seeing a single dime.
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
'Very awkward' moment Romeo Beckham's current and ex-girlfriend meet at influencer party. MOLLY CLAYTON was there - and saw every moment
When Romeo Beckham's current girlfriend Kim Turnbull and his ex Mia Regan ended up at the same bash on Thursday night, the event quickly gained an extra layer of intrigue.
Trump to welcome home six American troops killed in the Iran war at dignified transfer ceremony
President Donald Trump will attend the first dignified transfer ceremony for Iran war dead on Saturday.
Drug dealer admits killing vulnerable man who slept beside dogs
He had allegedly slept on a mattress in a garage beside dogs at a property in Essex
Catholic bishop, 69, accused of visiting mega-brothel 12 times in one month is dramatically arrested as he prepared to board flight to ROME
Emanuel Shaleta was arrested just days after reports he was headed to Rome. The disgraced clergyman was accused of salacious behavior and pocketing up to $1 million of his church's money.
Kaye Adams is accused of being a foul-mouthed aggressive bully who humiliated staff. I worked for her... this is what I saw, by CODIE BULLEN
To the public, Kaye Adams is the whip-sharp, straight-talking broadcaster who is not afraid to speak her mind on-air and will brush off any backlash.
Isla Fisher stuns in a quirky pencil skirt as she joins chic Nicky Hilton at Nina Ricci's Paris Fashion Week show
Isla Fisher looked stunning in a quirky pencil skirt as she joined chic Nicky Hilton at designer Nina Ricci's Paris Fashion Week show on Friday.
Louis Walsh accuses Simon Cowell of keeping him and Sharon Osbourne in the dark when it came to The X Factor's production after revealing they are no longer speaking
The Irish music manager, who worked with Boyzone and Westlife , was a judge on the ITV talent show from its inception in 2004 alongside Simone and Sharon.
Our TV critics have assembled the ULTIMATE guide of the...
The Daily Mail's TV critics have assembled a guide of the 19 best shows and films to stream this weekend.
Student, 18, drowned in flooded park after telling girlfriend man had tried to rape him on night out, inquest hears
Fintan Jack Feltham, 18, told his girlfriend Molly in the early hours of November 27 he had been in the town's Plush nightclub with friends when he was attacked and lost his glasses.
Furious Iranian influencers slam 'garbage' CNN reporter in Iran downplaying panic as 'shoot to kill' orders given
CNN's sole correspondent on the ground in Iran is facing backlash for his coverage inside the nation on day seven of the escalating war with the US and Israel.
Dark heart of Scotland's most elite schools exposed: Hotbeds of violence, racism and paedophilia. Mind-blowing pupil-on-pupil savagery. Slave auctions. As former pupils speak out on 'cesspits of sadism', GRAHAM GRANT'S shocking investigation
Nightmarish scenes echo William Golding's Lord Of The Flies, the dystopian novel about British schoolboys stranded on a deserted island who descend into savagery without adult supervision.
Jealous thug who murdered his ex-girlfriend's sister and her three young children after setting their house on fire given whole life term
Sharaz Ali, 40, who planned to 'wipe out a whole family' will never be released from prison for murdering his ex-girlfriend's sister and her three children.
Diesel prices rising faster than petrol as Iran conflict already triggers 6p-a-litre increase at the pumps
Increases at the pump mean filling a typical 55-litre family car with petrol has become £2 more expensive, with a rise of about £3.30 for diesel vehicles.
Pierce Brosnan smoulders with sunglasses and a slicked quiff as he channels his inner gangster once again filming MobLand season two
Piers Brosnan has been spotted smouldering on set in a pair of sunglasses and slicked quiff - channelling his inner gangster for MobLand season two.
Couple win legal battle with millionaire neighbours over tiny strip of land outside their £1.3m home after company boss who moved in next door installed garden gnome
Expert gardener Liz Dobson and her former British Airways executive partner Andrew Pleming, both 60, had long tended the tiny parcel of land outside their detached home in Dorking, Surrey.
NASA astronaut says humanity is 'living a lie' after spending 178 days in space
A NASA astronaut who completed nearly 3,000 orbits around Earth, discovering humanity has been 'living a lie.'
Essex charity marks International Women's Day by celebrating female staff
Open Road, which provides drug and alcohol support services across Essex and Medway, joined organisations around the world.
Four Essex women over 50 finish 3,000-mile world’s toughest row across Atlantic
They took on the challenge of rowing 3,000 miles across the Atlantic ocean and successfully finished it.
Proton Mail Helped FBI Unmask Anonymous 'Stop Cop City' Protester
Longtime Slashdot reader AmiMoJo shares a report from 404 Media: Privacy-focused email provider Proton Mail provided Swiss authorities with payment data that the FBI then used to determine who was allegedly behind an anonymous account affiliated with the Stop Cop City movement in Atlanta, according to a court record reviewed by 404 Media. The records provide insight into the sort of data that Proton Mail, which prides itself both on its end-to-end encryption and that it is only governed by Swiss privacy law, can and does provide to third parties. In this case, the Proton Mail account was affiliated with the Defend the Atlanta Forest (DTAF) group and Stop Cop City movement in Atlanta, which authorities were investigating for their connection to arson, vandalism and doxing. Broadly, members were protesting the building of a large police training center next to the Intrenchment Creek Park in Atlanta, and actions also included camping in the forest and lawsuits. Charges against more than 60 people have since been dropped.
Read more of this story at Slashdot.