Does Canada Need Nationalized, Public AI?
While AI CEOs worry governments might nationalize AI, others are advocating for something similar. Canadian security professional Bruce Schneier and Harvard data scientist Nathan Sanders published this call to action in Canada's most widely-read newspaper (with a readership over 6 million): "Canada Needs Nationalized, Public AI."
While there are Canadian AI companies, they remain for-profit enterprises, their interests not necessarily aligned with our collective good. The only real alternative is to be bold and invest in a wholly Canadian public AI: an AI model built and funded by Canada for Canadians, as public infrastructure. This would give Canadians access to the myriad of benefits from AI without having to depend on the U.S. or other countries. It would mean Canadian universities and public agencies building and operating AI models optimized not for global scale and corporate profit, but for practical use by Canadians...
We are already on our way to having AI become an inextricable part of society. To ensure stability and prosperity for this country, Canadian users and developers must be able to turn to AI models built, controlled, and operated publicly in Canada instead of building on corporate platforms, American or otherwise... [Switzerland's funding of a public AI model, Apertus] represents precisely the paradigm shift Canada should embrace: AI as public infrastructure, like systems for transportation, water, or electricity, rather than private commodity... Public AI systems can incorporate mechanisms for genuine public input and democratic oversight on critical ethical questions: how to handle copyrighted works in training data, how to mitigate bias, how to distribute access when demand outstrips capacity, and how to license use for sensitive applications like policing or medicine...
Canada already has many of the building blocks for public AI. The country has world-class AI research institutions, including the Vector Institute, Mila, and CIFAR, which pioneered much of the deep learning revolution. Canada's $2-billion Sovereign AI Compute Strategy provides substantial funding. What's needed now is a reorientation away from viewing this as an opportunity to attract private capital, and toward a fully open public AI model.
Long-time Slashdot reader sinij has a different opinion. "To me, this sounds dystopian, because I can also imagine AI declining your permits, renewal of license, or medication due to misalignment or 'greater good' reasons."
But the Schneier/Sanders essays argues this creates "an alternative ownership structure for AI technology" that is allocating decision-making authority and value "to national public institutions rather than foreign corporations."
Read more of this story at Slashdot.
Scientists reveal exactly where you're going WRONG on your dating profile - and the simple changes you can make to bag a date
Are you struggling to find love online? Scientists have revealed where you're probably going wrong.
PETER HITCHENS: Modish liberals wanted to keep Ian Huntley alive for years. And they call ME barbaric for backing the death penalty for heinous murderers like him
Is there anyone who is not relieved that Ian Huntley is dead? There is nothing to say in defence of the heinous Soham murderer. Yet modish liberals hoped to keep him alive for many years to come.
Police-style powers handed to Environment Agency in bid to crack down on waste criminals 'blighting our countryside'
Waste criminals are facing a tough crackdown as the government announces new 'zero-tolerance' plans to deal with gangs who illegally dump rubbish.
Missing Vítoria Barreto’s laptop found in Brightlingsea, loved ones confirm
Another significant item belonging to missing psychologist Vitória Figueiredo Barreto has been found in Brightlingsea.
Missing Vítoria Barreto’s laptop found in Brightlingsea, loved ones confirm
Another significant item belonging to missing psychologist Vitória Figueiredo Barreto has been found in Brightlingsea.
Will London be out of water by 2040?
Shocking new book reveals the devastating effects climate change could wreck upon the world, and how we can learn to live with it.
Why Viagra's not just for men: Women insist little blue pill has transformed their health, while medical experts say many more should take it (and this is the startling truth about what it does for your sex life)
For eight years, Gillian Murphy dreaded cold weather. Winter would leave the 71-year-old's fingers white and freezing - while her feet became agonisingly cold and impossible to warm up.
The London stereotypes moving to UK seaside towns - including 'DINKS' cashing in, wannabe B&B owners and retirees - and why life isn't always a beach when they get there
Invigorating sea walks, cheaper house prices and a real sense of community...the nation's seaside towns are ever more attractive to those tired of London life.
Three people taken to hospital following multi-vehicle crash on M11
The road was closed for several hours
'Of course I was violent, Jan… but I've never murdered anyone': JAN MOIR has an eye-popping encounter with Britain's answer to Pablo Escobar
Andrew Pritchard was once one of the biggest drug traffickers in Britain, our very own homegrown drug lord to rival Colombia's Pablo Escobar or Mexico 's El Chapo.
Michelle Keegan is 'mortified' and Mark Wright is 'fuming': Insiders tell KATIE HIND what the couple REALLY think of his mother and sister as Essex rivals celebrate downfall of the family
There has been much whinging and whining taking place within the Wright family this week.
I lost FOUR STONE in just six months on the simple 2010s diet that 'works as well as fat jabs' - this is how YOU can do the same in time for summer
It's the kind of diet more often spotted advertising on shopping channels or tucked away in late-night television slots than splashed across glossy celebrity Instagram feeds.
Everton star claims club's fans 'ATTACKED' his friends in Arsenal away end: Shocking footage posted by Thierno Barry shows violent clashes between supporters as police launch investigation
Barry was named as a substitute for the Toffees' cash with the Premier League leaders, coming on in the second-half in place of Beto, and shared footage from the stadium after the game.
Inside Frankie Dettori's rollercoaster life: From cocaine bust to bulimia battle and cheating death in plane crash - now legendary jockey faces possible stint in jail
As legendary jockey Frankie Dettori embarks upon the next chapter of his life and faces the threat of jail time, it is worth a closer look at his extraordinary story so far.
Prue Leith, 85, reveals the health concern that caused her to step down from Bake Off
When she announced she was stepping down from Bake Off, Prue Leith explained she wanted to enjoy more time off work.
One of her husbands was gay, one of her boyfriends (Peter Sellers) was mad, her mother was a suicidal wreck and Lady Gaga mortified her at the Oscars...in her new memoir Liza Minelli reveals how she's always come out on top
Her life has been a macabre cabaret but Liza Minelli's got through it all alive and kicking
Two vehicle crash in Essex town leaves road closed
Emergency services attended the scene
PATRICK BISHOP: No measure of Great Britain's shrunken status is so poignant as the decline to insignificance of our once mighty Navy
You do not have to be an Empire nostalgist to weep at the pitiful state of today's Navy.
London's Burning star John Alford is found dead in jail weeks after he was imprisoned for sexually abusing two young girls
Alford, 54, was unresponsive on his bed when staff opened his cell door on Friday, it was reported.